Final statement: Frédéric Provencher and Glencore Canada Corporation
Summary
- On March 6, 2026, the Canadian National Contact Point (“NCP”) received a Request for Review from an individual resident (“the Notifier”) of Rouyn-Noranda, Quebec, concerning Glencore Canada Corporation (“Glencore”, “the Respondent”) and the Horne Smelter.
- The Notifier alleges that arsenic emissions from the Horne Smelter are associated with adverse health and environmental impacts on residents of Rouyn-Noranda and that Glencore has not taken adequate measures to prevent and mitigate those impacts. The complaint raises issues under Chapters II (General Policies), IV (Human Rights) and VI (Environment) of the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises on Responsible Business Conduct (“the Guidelines”).
- The Notifier asks the NCP to recommend, among other things, that Glencore achieve an annual average arsenic concentration of 3 ng/m³ within five years, implement ISASMELT or equivalent technology, establish independent emissions monitoring, engage in structured dialogue with the community and contribute to a community health fund.
- Following its assessment, the NCP concluded that the issues raised do not warrant further examination. In the particular circumstances of this case, the NCP considers that the nature of the issues and outcomes sought, together with the extent to which they are already being addressed through regulatory and judicial processes, leave limited scope for the NCP to make a distinct and meaningful contribution under the Guidelines. The NCP therefore concludes the specific instance without offering its good offices to the parties.
- The NCP’s decision does not constitute a finding as to whether Glencore Canada Corporation has observed or not observed the Guidelines. Consistent with its practice, the Canadian NCP does not make such determinations in specific instances.
- In accordance with the Canadian NCP’s procedures, a draft of this Statement was shared with both parties for review and comment prior to publication. The Statement was also shared with the Swiss NCP, given that Glencore Canada Corporation forms part of the Glencore group and its ultimate parent, Glencore plc, is headquartered in Switzerland.
1. Substance of the specific instance
1.1 Parties
The Notifier
- Frédéric Provencher is a resident of Rouyn-Noranda, Quebec. He states that he is directly affected by emissions from the Horne Smelter and is a member of the community exposed to arsenic emissions from the facility.
The Respondent
- Glencore Canada Corporation is a Canadian corporation headquartered in Toronto, Ontario, and forms part of the Glencore group, whose ultimate parent, Glencore plc, is headquartered in Baar, Switzerland. Glencore Canada has mining and metals operations in Canada and operates the Horne Smelter in Rouyn-Noranda, Quebec, which is the facility at issue in this specific instance. Glencore Canada confirmed in its response that the Horne Smelter belongs to Glencore Canada Corporation.
1.2 Summary of the complaint
- The Notifier alleges that arsenic emissions from the Horne Smelter expose residents of Rouyn-Noranda to adverse health and environmental impacts. He states that the annual average arsenic concentration measured at the ALTSP1 monitoring station in 2024 was 39 ng/m³, compared with the 3 ng/m³ value established under Quebec’s Clean Air Regulation. He considers the level of emissions to present an ongoing risk to the health of residents living near the Smelter. The Notifier further submits that Bill 11, adopted in June 2026, postponed by approximately two years the deadline for achieving the interim target of 15 ng/m³ and extended the framework applicable to the Smelter to 2033. He further notes that, in a March 20, 2026 letter to Quebec’s Ministry of Health and Social Services, the Direction de santé publique de l’Abitibi-Témiscamingue characterized the current annual target of 45 ng/m³ as presenting a risk deemed unacceptable by public health authorities.
- The Notifier alleges that Glencore has not taken adequate measures to reduce these emissions despite, in his view, having the financial and technological capacity to do so. He points in particular to Glencore’s decision not to proceed with the Aeris modernization project, its decision not to implement ISASMELT technology, which is marketed by Glencore Technology and used at other smelting facilities (one of the reported benefits of the technology is that it has lower emissions), and the creation of a buffer zone around the Smelter. He argues that these decisions demonstrate that Glencore has not adequately prevented or mitigated the alleged adverse impacts at their source.
- The Notifier also raises concerns regarding Glencore's voluntary arsenic biomonitoring program. He refers to written comments provided by Health Canada on the program's report, which, according to the Notifier, questioned the robustness of its principal conclusion and indicated that, when data from cycle 7 (2023–2024) of the Canadian Health Measures Survey are taken into account, arsenic concentrations observed among participating residents were higher than those measured in the current Canadian population. He further cites media reports indicating that the Direction de santé publique de l’Abitibi-Témiscamingue questioned the independence and scientific standards of the study.
- The Notifier alleges that these circumstances are inconsistent with Chapters II (General Policies), IV (Human Rights) and VI (Environment) of the Guidelines. Under Chapter II, he alleges that Glencore has not taken adequate steps to prevent and mitigate adverse impacts associated with its operations. Under Chapter IV, he alleges that continued exposure to arsenic emissions adversely affects the health and human rights of residents and that Glencore has not adequately addressed those impacts. Under Chapter VI, he alleges that Glencore has not adequately assessed and addressed the environmental, health and safety effects of the Smelter’s operations, including through the use of available emissions-reduction measures and technologies.
- The Notifier asks the NCP to recommend that Glencore: (i) commit to achieving an annual average arsenic concentration of 3 ng/m³ within five years, with intermediate annual targets; (ii) implement ISASMELT or equivalent technology; (iii) establish an independent emissions-monitoring system with monthly publication of results; (iv) establish structured dialogue with the Rouyn-Noranda community, including residents of the Notre-Dame neighbourhood; and (v) contribute to a community health fund.
1.3 Respondent's position
- Glencore disputes the Notifier's characterization of 3 ng/m³ as the applicable arsenic standard for the Horne Smelter. According to Glencore, the Smelter operates under ministerial authorizations issued under Quebec's Environment Quality Act, with a current authorized target of 45 ng/m³ at the legal monitoring station. Glencore states that the 3 ng/m³ value cited by the Notifier does not apply to the Horne Smelter and that exceeding that value does not in itself demonstrate an actual health risk.
- Glencore states that it has made significant investments to reduce the Smelter's environmental footprint and that the annual average concentration of arsenic measured at the monitoring station has declined by more than 70% since 2005. Glencore also states that authorized arsenic targets for the Smelter have been progressively reduced over time and that the Smelter has met the applicable targets. It explains that the Aeris project underwent a feasibility assessment but was ultimately not pursued because full implementation would have affected the stability and viability of the facility and delayed achievement of emission-reduction objectives. Glencore states that it is instead pursuing an optimized approach intended to achieve an annual average concentration of 15 ng/m³. With respect to ISASMELT, Glencore states that although it owns and markets the technology, it is not suitable for the particular configuration and operations of the Horne Smelter.
- Glencore also refers to its environmental and human rights policies, its participation in the Mining Association of Canada's Towards Sustainable Mining initiative, and third-party validation against the International Council on Mining and Metals Performance Expectations. It states that these systems demonstrate its commitment to environmental management, human rights and continuous improvement.
- Glencore further points to existing community engagement mechanisms and a voluntary arsenic biomonitoring program launched in 2025. It states that five sampling campaigns were conducted between April 2025 and January 2026, involving more than 1,300 samples. According to Glencore, the program was designed and led by an independent consulting firm, its methodology and final report were subject to peer review, and the results were presented to Health Canada and Environment and Climate Change Canada.Glencore subsequently informed the NCP that the results, released in June 2026, indicated that participating residents were not more exposed to arsenic than the general Canadian population and that distance from the Smelter was not an indicator of arsenic exposure.
- Finally, Glencore notes that substantially similar allegations are the subject of an ongoing class action before the Superior Court of Quebec and are subject to provincial regulatory oversight. It argues that further consideration by the NCP would not materially advance the purposes of the Guidelines.
- The Notifier subsequently provided additional information in response to Glencore’s submissions and maintained his request that the NCP continue its examination.
2. Initial assessment
- The NCP's initial assessment is based on the information provided by the Notifier, publicly available information, and information subsequently provided by the Respondent.
- In accordance with the Procedures for NCPs under the Guidelines, the NCP has considered whether the issues raised warrant further examination, taking into account the identity of the parties and their interest in the matter; whether the issues are material and substantiated; whether the Respondent is covered by the Guidelines; whether there appears to be a link between the Respondent's activities and the issues raised; the extent to which applicable law or parallel proceedings may limit the NCP's ability to contribute to the resolution of the issues or the implementation of the Guidelines; and whether examination of the issues would contribute to the purposes and effectiveness of the Guidelines.
- A decision that the issues warrant further examination does not mean that they have been given final consideration, does not validate the allegations raised by the Notifier, and does not imply a finding as to whether the Respondent has acted consistently with the Guidelines. It means only that the threshold for further consideration under the NCP process has been met.
2.1 Identity of the parties and their interest in the matter
- The Notifier is a resident of Rouyn-Noranda, Quebec, where the Horne Smelter is located. He states that he is directly affected by emissions from the Smelter and is a member of the community potentially affected by the issues raised in the specific instance. The NCP is satisfied that the Notifier has an interest in the matters raised.
2.2. Whether the enterprise is covered by the Guidelines
- Glencore Canada Corporation is a Canadian corporation headquartered in Toronto, Ontario, and operates the Horne Smelter in Rouyn-Noranda, Quebec. It forms part of the Glencore group, whose ultimate parent, Glencore plc, is headquartered in Switzerland. Glencore Canada confirmed that the Horne Smelter belongs to Glencore Canada Corporation. The NCP considers that Glencore Canada Corporation is a multinational enterprise covered by the Guidelines and that the Canadian NCP is competent to consider the issues raised in this specific instance.
- The NCP considers that there is a clear link between Glencore Canada’s activities and the issues raised in the specific instance. Glencore Canada owns and operates the Horne Smelter, and the complaint concerns potential human rights, health and environmental impacts associated with emissions from the Smelter and the measures taken by Glencore to manage and reduce those emissions. Glencore Canada confirmed in its response that the Horne Smelter belongs to Glencore Canada Corporation. The NCP therefore considers that this criterion is met.
2.3 Whether the issues are material and substantiated
- The issues raised are material to the Guidelines. The complaint concerns potential adverse human rights, health and environmental impacts associated with arsenic emissions from the Horne Smelter and raises issues under Chapters II (General Policies), IV (Human Rights) and VI (Environment) of the Guidelines. In particular, the complaint raises questions concerning the steps taken by Glencore to identify, assess, prevent and mitigate potential adverse impacts associated with the Smelter’s operations.
- The NCP also considers that the issues are sufficiently substantiated for the purposes of the Initial Assessment. The complaint provides information concerning arsenic concentrations measured in the vicinity of the Smelter and identifies specific decisions and measures that the Notifier considers inadequate to address the risks, including the Aeris project and the use of emissions-reduction technologies.
- Glencore disputes a number of the factual and technical conclusions advanced by the Notifier, including the characterization of 3 ng/m³ as the applicable standard and the alleged health implications of the measured arsenic concentrations. Glencore also points to measures it has taken to reduce emissions, its environmental management systems and the results of its 2025–2026 biomonitoring program.
- These differences between the parties do not, in themselves, mean that the issues are not substantiated for the purposes of the Initial Assessment. At this stage, the NCP considers that the information provided is sufficient to establish that the issues raised are material and substantiated for the purposes of applying this criterion.
2.4 Link between the enterprise's activities and the issues raised
- The NCP considers that there is a clear link between Glencore Canada’s activities and the issues raised in the specific instance. Glencore Canada owns and operates the Horne Smelter, and the complaint concerns potential human rights, health and environmental impacts associated with emissions from the Smelter and the measures taken by Glencore to manage and reduce those emissions. Glencore Canada confirmed in its response that the Horne Smelter belongs to Glencore Canada Corporation. The NCP therefore considers that this criterion is met.
2.5 Applicable law and parallel proceedings
- The Horne Smelter is subject to environmental regulation in Quebec, including ministerial authorizations issued pursuant to Quebec’s Environment Quality Act. Glencore states that the current authorization establishes an annual average arsenic concentration target of 45 ng/m³ at the legal monitoring station and disputes the Notifier’s position that the 3 ng/m³ value under Quebec’s Clean Air Regulation applies to the Smelter.
- The NCP also notes that a class action concerning arsenic emissions from the Horne Smelter has been authorized by the Superior Court of Quebec and will proceed to trial on the merits. According to the Notifier, on September 21, 2026, the Quebec Court of Appeal allowed an appeal concerning the scope of the authorized class and modified the period covered by one of the subgroups.
- There is substantial overlap between the specific instance and the class action, including with respect to arsenic emissions, alleged health impacts and measures taken to reduce emissions. There is also overlap in some of the outcomes sought.
- The NCP has taken the applicable regulatory framework and the extent of the overlap with the ongoing court proceedings into account in its assessment.
2.6 Contribution to the purposes and effectiveness of the Guidelines
- The NCP considered whether further examination of the specific instance could contribute to resolving the issues raised or to the implementation of the Guidelines. In doing so, the NCP considered the specific recommendations of the Guidelines invoked by the Notifier and the outcomes sought through the complaint.
- With respect to Chapter II (General Policies), the Notifier raises concerns regarding Glencore's approach to preventing and mitigating potential adverse impacts associated with arsenic emissions from the Horne Smelter. The complaint relates these concerns principally to the level of arsenic emissions and the measures Glencore has taken, or should take, to reduce those emissions. These matters are closely connected to the environmental conditions governing the Smelter's operations and to issues concerning emissions and mitigation measures that are already being addressed through the Quebec regulatory framework and ongoing court proceedings.
- With respect to Chapter IV (Human Rights), the Notifier raises concerns regarding potential impacts of arsenic emissions on the health of residents of Rouyn-Noranda and Glencore's responsibility to prevent and mitigate adverse human rights impacts. The alleged health impacts of the smelter's emissions are also central to the ongoing class action. Further examination of these allegations by the NCP would therefore engage many of the same factual questions concerning exposure, potential health impacts and the adequacy of measures taken to address them that are being considered in those proceedings.
- With respect to Chapter VI (Environment), the Notifier raises concerns regarding Glencore's environmental management and its assessment and mitigation of the environmental, health and safety effects of its operations. In particular, the complaint questions Glencore's decisions concerning emissions-reduction measures and technologies, including the Aeris project and ISASMELT technology. These concerns substantially overlap with matters subject to regulatory oversight and issues raised in the class action concerning emissions and measures taken to reduce emissions.
- The NCP also considered the specific outcomes sought by the Notifier, including that Glencore achieve an annual average arsenic concentration of 3 ng/m³ within five years, implement ISASMELT or equivalent technology, establish independent emissions monitoring, engage in structured community dialogue, and contribute to a community health fund. While the underlying human rights and environmental concerns are relevant to the Guidelines, several of these requested outcomes would require the NCP to engage directly in questions concerning the appropriate emissions level, technology, monitoring arrangements or remedial measures. These are not outcomes prescribed by the Guidelines and, in this case, substantially intersect with matters already subject to regulatory or judicial processes.
- The NCP further notes that mechanisms already exist for community engagement and for raising concerns, including a Liaison Committee, the Comité de Vigie, a community relations office, and established complaint mechanisms. According to Glencore, these also include its Raising Concerns program, which permits anonymous reporting and is administered independently from Baar, a quarterly newsletter, an advertised community complaint process, and ongoing engagement through municipal council meetings and the Rouyn-Noranda Chamber of Commerce.
- Taking these circumstances together, the NCP considers that further examination would leave limited scope for a distinct and meaningful contribution under the Guidelines. The principal Guidelines issues identified by the Notifier cannot readily be separated from the regulatory, technical and factual matters already being addressed through existing processes, while several of the specific outcomes sought would require the NCP to enter into matters more appropriately addressed through those processes. The NCP therefore considers that further examination would be unlikely to contribute meaningfully to resolving the issues raised or to the purposes and effectiveness of the Guidelines.
3. Conclusion
- The NCP concludes, on the basis of the Initial Assessment set out above, that the issues raised in the specific instance do not warrant further examination under the Guidelines. This decision does not constitute a finding as to whether the Respondent has observed the Guidelines.
- In reaching this conclusion, the NCP has applied the Initial Assessment criteria set out in paragraph 33 of the Commentary on the Procedures for NCPs. These require the NCP to consider, among other factors, the extent to which applicable law and/or parallel proceedings limit the NCP’s ability to contribute to the resolution of the issues or the implementation of the Guidelines, and whether examination of the issues would contribute to the purposes and effectiveness of the Guidelines.
- The NCP recognizes that several of the Initial Assessment criteria are satisfied. The Notifier has an interest in the matters raised; Glencore Canada Corporation is an enterprise covered by the Guidelines; the issues raised are material and sufficiently substantiated for the purposes of the Initial Assessment; and there is a clear link between Glencore Canada’s operation of the Horne Smelter and the issues raised. The complaint raises concerns relevant to Chapters II (General Policies), IV (Human Rights) and VI (Environment) of the Guidelines.
- However, the Initial Assessment requires the NCP to consider the criteria as a whole in determining whether the issues warrant further examination. Of particular importance in this specific instance are the final two criteria concerning the effect of applicable law and parallel proceedings on the NCP’s ability to contribute, and whether further examination would contribute to the purposes and effectiveness of the Guidelines.
- The NCP recognizes that the existence of parallel proceedings does not, in itself, prevent an NCP from offering good offices. Paragraph 35 of the Commentary on the Procedures for NCPs provides that, where parallel proceedings exist, NCPs should evaluate whether an offer of good offices could make a positive contribution to the resolution of the issues raised and/or the implementation of the Guidelines going forward, while also considering whether it would create serious prejudice for parties involved in those proceedings or a contempt of court situation.
- The NCP has therefore considered whether, notwithstanding the ongoing regulatory and judicial processes, there is a distinct and meaningful contribution that the NCP could make through further examination and good offices. The NCP does not consider that there is sufficient scope for such a contribution in the circumstances of this specific instance.
- The overlap with the authorized class action is substantial and goes to the core of the complaint. Both concern arsenic emissions from the Horne Smelter, alleged health impacts on surrounding residents, and the adequacy of measures taken to reduce emissions. There is also overlap in the outcomes sought. The class action has been authorized and will proceed to trial on the merits.
- The NCP also considered whether the issues could be sufficiently separated from those proceedings to allow for a useful and distinct dialogue under the Guidelines. In the NCP’s view, meaningful examination of the principal concerns raised would necessarily engage many of the same factual and substantive questions already being addressed through the Quebec regulatory framework or before the courts. These include the level and potential impacts of arsenic emissions, the adequacy of measures taken to reduce those emissions, and decisions concerning particular technologies and investments. The NCP is not an appropriate forum for determining the legally applicable emissions standard, establishing liability for alleged health impacts, or determining whether Glencore should implement a particular technology or operational solution.
- The NCP has also considered whether good offices could make a distinct contribution through additional dialogue concerning community engagement and the management of concerns associated with the Smelter. In doing so, the NCP has taken into account the mechanisms already available, including the Liaison Committee, the Comité de Vigie, a community relations office and established complaint mechanisms, as well as the information provided by Glencore concerning its biomonitoring program and other engagement with community stakeholders.
- Taking these circumstances together, the NCP does not consider that an offer of good offices could make the positive contribution contemplated by paragraph 35 of the Commentary on the Procedures for NCPs. Nor does the NCP consider that further examination of the issues would make a meaningful additional contribution to the purposes and effectiveness of the Guidelines, as contemplated by paragraph 33. The final two Initial Assessment criteria therefore weigh decisively against further examination of this specific instance.
- Accordingly, after considering all of the Initial Assessment criteria, the NCP has determined that the issues raised do not warrant further examination. In accordance with Part I.C.4(a) of the Procedures, where an NCP decides that the issues raised do not warrant further examination, it will issue a statement describing the issues raised and the reasons for its decision. The NCP therefore concludes the specific instance without an offer of good offices.
Timeline
- March 6, 2026 – NCP receives the Notifier’s Request for Review.
- March 13, 2026 – NCP acknowledges receipt of the Request for Review.
- March 19, 2026 – NCP shares the Request for Review with the Respondent.
- April 17, 2026 – NCP receives the Respondent’s response to the complaint.
- May 1, 2026 – Respondent requests a call with the NCP.
- May 26, 2026 – NCP holds an initial call with the Respondent.
- July 30, 2026 – NCP receives additional information from the Respondent.
- August–September 2026 – NCP receives additional submissions and information from the Notifier.
- Date modified: